Why Staffing Numbers Alone Won’t Win a Nursing Home Case
Can staffing numbers alone win a nursing home case? Not without a bridge to the resident’s injury. In this special episode, nursing home abuse lawyer Rob Schenk welcomes Ernie Tosh back to the show to explain bridge witnesses, how resident acuity shows what staffing a facility should have had, and why the Five-Star staffing rating reflects what’s typical instead of what residents actually need. They also share what attorneys can expect at the Summit South CLE in Charleston, South Carolina, on January 14–15, 2027.
Intro
Tosh:
Their acuity dictated that they needed 5.2 hours of staffing, but they’re only staffed at 4.6, so what? What does that mean? And that’s where judges get bogged down. And I feel so convinced when I look at a case that anybody who sees these numbers should immediately have the same reaction I do. That’s not true.
Guest Intro
Schenk:
Ernie Tosh started his career as a prosecutor in Fort Worth, Texas, before he found his passion in nursing home litigation. He’s tried more than 150 jury trials and he’s known for bringing Medicare and Medicaid cost report analysis into nursing home cases. And he’s testified before Congress on private equity and health.
Okay, folks, so this one’s a little bit different. Ernie and I recorded this episode to talk about the Summit South.
But I dislike podcast commercials. This is not a commercial for the Summit CLE. It’s not. You are going to learn things in this episode, but we do talk about what you can expect to learn at the summit, which is a ton and I highly recommend it.
Who Is the Summit For, and What Is It Designed to Teach?
Schenk:
I just want to say that I loved the Denver Summit. I learned so much. And if I can convince my wife, I will also be going to the Charleston Summit. But tell us out there, Ernie, who should go to this summit? Who is this summit for? What’s it designed to teach you?
Tosh:
So this summit is for really any attorneys that do nursing home work. So it’s kind of a nuts and bolts, both technically, you know, from the beginning of your case through your jury verdict. It’s touching on a lot of the technical aspects, but what makes it very different is at the same time, we’re teaching the presentation at jury portion, you know, how you get this information, where you get this information, but then how you weave that into the story you’re telling the jury.
How Do the Staffing Data and the Jury Story Work Together?
Schenk:
And so I imagine that’s why it’s you and Ken Connor. So Ken Connor is the one that is talking about the aspect of convincing a jury based on the evidence. And you’re the one that kind of teaches how to acquire the evidence.
Tosh:
Correct. So I teach more of the technical aspect of, you know, these are your RFPs that you’re using. When you go do these depositions, you know, these are your top four or five depositions. You know, here’s outlines of stuff that I use in my depositions. And so that portion of it is very hands-on. And it’s not so much a lecture format as it is a give and take discussion.
You know, we have every level of attorney in there from someone who’s doing their second or third nursing home case and they realize their first one didn’t go as well as they would like it to, and they’re looking for more information, all the way up to people who’ve done this for 15 years, and this is all they do. And so, when you have those people in one room, you’ve got maybe a newer person asking a question that one of these 15-year practitioners is an expert on.
And then, boom, you get to have a great discussion right there in the middle of that, you know, of that presentation. And so, that’s what I got really excited at the summit in Denver because that went on all day, both days. It was such a great give and take. And some of the really high level practitioners had questions. It was like, hey, well, what do you guys do when this happens?
And so, you know, because we’re all coming from different jurisdictions. And so different things happen in California than happen in Ohio. And so it’s fantastic.
Schenk:
I can attest to that. There were at least a few times where I ask a question, and then there’s somebody, you know, like for example, Gary Rodin, you know, 20 plus years trying cases and nursing homes. Like, Rob, no, like, don’t worry about getting bogged down into this specific thing. Like just because, you know, somebody driving drunk, and this being the analogy to understaffing, just because somebody was driving drunk for 10 straight days and nothing happened doesn’t mean that that person was safe for those 10 days, right?
What Is a Bridge Witness in a Staffing Case?
Schenk:
So anyway, I digress. What I want to do, Ernie, if you don’t mind, I think I have an understanding. I think the audience has an understanding of kind of what they can expect. But I want to kind of talk about a couple of things that I thought were really, really interesting that I learned. And I’m not giving away too much of anything because this is like one teeny tiny percentage of what you learn at this summit.
But talk to me about the idea of what you’re calling a bridge witness. What is a bridge witness and why are they important in a staffing case?
Tosh:
Sure. So when you look at staffing in a nursing home case, you know, we’re looking at every bit of staffing data we can get to. And that is my passion is the staffing, understaffing portion, because almost all our injuries are driven by understaffing. But once you get to that number, you know, oh, their acuity dictated that they needed 5.2 hours of staffing, but they’re only staffed at 4.6.
That difference is substantial. It works out the X number of hours per week that that person wasn’t getting the care that they needed. So there’s your number. Here’s this number over here that’s like, oh, they were short eight tenths of an hour per patient per day. So what? What does that mean? And that’s where judges get bogged down in the what is the relevance of that number to my injury over here in the med mal side of this case.
Because I look at the case as being kind of a bifurcated med mal case with a corporate malfeasance component. And that number is over in my corporate malfeasance side of the case. You need to have a bridge witness. Arches from the numbers to the injury. And that’s what I call a bridge witness. And that is usually going to be your nursing expert who comes in and says, yeah, I saw those calculations.
I understand how they do the calculations. And I agree that this number over here is a breach of the standard of care. And when you look at our injury, this type of injury is directly caused by understaffing. And the evidence of that in this case is X, Y, and Z. Look at the lack of documentation. Look at the altered documentation. Look at the fact that there’s no RN ever in the medical record for 60 straight days.
So there’s all the evidence of understaffing right there in your documentation. And that witness is gonna pull the numbers over from your corporate malfeasance side. And that, as soon as you can get the judge to understand this staffing led to my injury, then it becomes relevant, and he or she will let you present it to the jury.
Related reading: What are the types of nursing home staff?
How Do You Know How Much Staff Residents’ Acuity Requires?
Schenk:
Another thing that I thought was really interesting was the concept of how we got to know how much staff is needed for the particular acuity of the resident population. And that understanding, I say it started, but it became more clear in the mid 90s with the STM. And then that progressed to something else and now we’re on to something else. So can you kind of, from a 40,000-foot view, talk about what the STM study accomplished and kind of where we are now with understanding staffing to acuity?
Tosh:
Sure. So, federal regulation, and every state follows this as well, states that the facility must staff to the needs of each individual based on their individual resident assessment tool. Parsing that out, the resident assessment tool is the minimum data set. It’s the MDS. It’s in every one of your medical records or should be. It is a long assessment, 45 pages long. Talks about how much care they need for turning and repositioning, for eating, for dressing, everything about this person.
So great assessment. At the end of that assessment, in Section Z, as in zebra, and the technical cell is cell 0100, there’s a code that’s currently called a PDPM code, and that’s the reimbursement for that person. That’s how much the government’s gonna pay for that person’s care. And that code is generated by CMS’s software that looks at everything in that assessment and says this is how much we’re gonna pay for the care of that person.
Embedded in that code is that patient’s acuity, how much nursing care they need. Well, we know by pulling out that person’s acuity, we can go back to the STM time study that you mentioned. It was done in the mid-90s. And we can take their acuity score. Let’s say it’s a, you know, letter B as in boy. We go over to that time study and we can say a letter B needs this much RN time, LPN time, and aide time.
Okay, we know how much care that person needs. That would be our person. We have their medical records. Probably. My person is one of 120 residents. So that doesn’t really help us. Unless you have the MDS for everybody in the facility. And I do. I have 350 million MDSs in our database. And so, and we get more every six months. We sued CMS for three years to get that information.
And so, with that information, we can literally tell you any facility in the country on any day since January 1st, 2012, exactly what they should have been staffed at based on the acuity of their residents. And that’s what’s important. We’re not talking about a state average, national average, anything like that. We are saying this facility got paid for a certain amount of staffing and then they staffed significantly below that.
Related reading (Noridian Medicare): SNF PDPM
Related reading: How do I get medical records after a Georgia nursing home injury?
Why Is the Five-Star Staffing Rating Different From Staffing to Acuity?
Schenk:
And so now tell me, you mentioned average. Tell me, like, tell me why it’s not necessarily irrelevant, but what you’re saying is nothing to do with the Five-Star rating on staffing. Why are those two things, what you just described and the Five-Star rating on staffing, different things?
Tosh:
Because the Five-Star rating and staffing, crazy, the methodology that we use to do our calculation is exactly what CMS was doing before April 1st, 2018. They used to publish the acuity level for the facilities around the country. They use this exact methodology. Go grab the MDSs, use the time study, and then they would give a Five-Star rating based on how you are staffed to your acuity, which is exactly how it should be done.
But in 2018, CMS overruled their expert panel and decided they would go to a different system, which is basically how does this facility staff compared to other facilities in their state? And they don’t really consider acuity that much. And so it’s more of a, if you’re staffed consistent with most of the other people in the state, and they do basically look at the acuity and say, so let’s say your acuity is a level B acuity.
How does your facility staff to a level B compared to other facilities? Well, as we know, chronic understaffing is prevalent through the industry. So, what you’re doing is you’re saying, how are you staffing versus everybody else that’s understaffed? Right. And so the Five-Star system now, that staffing rating is meaningless.
Schenk:
It’s about what’s typical as opposed to what the resident needs.
Tosh:
That’s exactly right.
The Summit South CLE: Dates and Registration
Schenk:
Folks, if you handle nursing home abuse cases, mark your calendar. The Summit South is a two-day CLE for plaintiffs, nursing home attorneys, and paralegals. And it’s January 14th through January 15th of 2027 in Charleston, South Carolina. And again, that’s January 14th and 15th, which is a Thursday and Friday of 2027. And it’s going to be special because it’s Ernie Tosh and the amazing Ken Connor who are going to walk you through a case from intake to verdict, staffing data, corporate structure, money trail, and then how to turn those numbers into a story a jury will actually feel.
Seating is capped, so it stays as a real conversation. And every registration includes the hardbound Summit Field Manual. You can register for this amazing event at thesummitcle.com. Again, that’s thesummitcle.com. Questions about registration or where to stay, call or text the program chair Casey Gray at 229-292-9487. Again, that’s Casey over at 229-292-9487. And I hope to see you in Charleston.
Related reading (The Summit CLE): The Summit South: Nursing Home Litigation in Charleston
Why Do the Numbers Need a Human Story in Front of a Jury?
Schenk:
So, and again, we get into the weeds with this data stuff with Ernie, but remember that Ernie is only 50% of the summit. So just imagine how the summit works: Ernie’s going to talk just like he’s talking now, but then Ken Connor is going to step up in a more human form and talk with beauty. Like this guy, I don’t know, man. Like, he’s a really, really good speaker, but not that Ernie’s not a good speaker.
I’m just saying, like, you’re going to get math, like, Ernie’s the math guy. And then Ken Connor’s going to sit up and go, okay, now that we’ve heard all that about the averages and STM and all these studies, here’s how we talk to the jury and educate the jury about this in a convincing way. And that’s, to me, that’s the gold of the summit: you have both worlds, like you learn numbers, and you learn how to deliver the numbers in a way that a normal layperson can understand.
Tosh:
Right. Ken brings humanity. And I’ve said forever: when I grow up, I’d like to be Ken Connor. He is the best orator I’ve ever heard. And when he gets up to speak and he starts talking about, you know, human dignity and how our residents were stripped of the dignity that all humans are entitled to and are born with, and then weaves in the understaffing and the technical side of our depositions.
He helps us tell the story because my dry data driven stuff is awesome to me. I love that stuff. I live in that world. I love the data. And I feel so convinced when I look at a case that it’s this, anybody who sees these numbers should immediately have the same reaction I do. That’s not true. Just like you say, talking to a lay person about this.
I get on an airplane and somebody next to me asks me what I do. Do you think they want to hear any of the crap we just talked about? Of course not. No way. No, I mean, they’re putting their headset on one sentence in. But if you start the conversation with, I try to protect elderly individuals in nursing homes and try to preserve and enforce their dignity.
That’s a different conversation. And when you can have that conversation and weave in the technical aspect of it, and that’s what Ken is a master at. He is the best storyteller.
Schenk:
Completely changes. There was a point in this Denver Summit where he kind of pulled out an excerpt from a closing that he gave, or maybe he’s done this many times. I don’t know. But it was the excerpt from The Velveteen Rabbit and connecting, like, you know, Miss Johnson, you know, was blind in one eye, you know, paralyzed on one side, and, you know, connecting that to The Velveteen Rabbit of like, you know, but we still love The Velveteen Rabbit, right? Like, and like, there wasn’t a dry eye in the house. It was amazing. So I guess I want to reiterate that you get the numbers, you get the nerd stuff, but then you get this beautiful orator that teaches you how to say it like a normal person.
Tosh:
It’s true. It’s true.
Schenk:
And I think people out there would be like, God, Rob, you’re making Ernie sound like he’s not a normal person.
Tosh:
I’m not a normal person. Ernie’s not a normal person.
Schenk:
You wear that with a badge of honor. And I only say that because I feel like I’m also a nerd. Like I’m not anywhere near your level in terms of the intellect to be able to understand spreadsheets. But like my mind, how I naturally come, is to go to the zeros and ones and just give me data. Like, I don’t know if I’m, it’s, that’s just,
Tosh:
It makes sense. It makes sense to me. We are wired to process that data, see those patterns. Um, and Ken, you know, I’ve been down that rabbit hole for so long that I love just talking to Ken about my cases, about his cases. Ken and I have worked a ton of cases together. Um, it’s, and this summit was his idea. He was like, I think you and I should do a summit because we look at cases in such a different light.
And if we can bring them together and create, in my mind, because I’m a nerd, a Venn diagram of this stuff and my stuff and get them to overlap and have people live in that overlap. Um, that is unbelievably powerful. I used Ken’s humanity in a case in Miami that I’m not going to get into the particulars other than to say that case went super sideways right at the end.
And we were in mediation 30 days before we were going to pick jury, and we were struggling on that case. Went in, used Ken’s humanity argument with our mediator. And he was completely bought in. During the discussion, during the day, I was weaving in our numbers. Boom, boom. End of the story. At the end of the day, we resolved that case for three times what we thought we were going to get that day.
And I called Ken on the way out of that mediation and told him, I just want you to know, my family does not realize that it was you that got them this settlement. There were eight children, all immigrants from Haiti. This was more money than they could ever conceive. And it was because Ken brought the humanity and taught me how to be a human as opposed to a robot.
And I think, I mean, really personally, I think that’s the power of the summit. I don’t see my stuff as being all that much. I just know technically how to collect data and how to help other people get it in their cases. What Ken brings, he brings the humanity. And man, it will juice your case.
How Can a CNA Show How Long Resident Care Actually Takes?
Schenk:
That’s, it’s true. Ken is a legend, but I don’t want you to beat up on yourself because what you provide, and I’ll give you another example. This is another example. So I understand PBJ. I understand people in the building. I understand the time studies. But something that I learned from you that now I’m doing in my cases is asking a CNA to go through the activities of daily living, and you tell me how long does it take to change a bed sheet, right?
I want you to picture yourself in that facility. Like, where are the linens? Do you have to walk down a hallway? How long does it take to walk down the hallway? Like, put your, let’s put me there. And so, you build a record and not just change the sheets, but like, how long is it to help someone get to the wheelchair and wheel them out to lunch or to bathe somebody?
And you’re building this, you know, how much time it actually takes to do these things. And then you can present that on top of the extra data. So, man, like, like I said, I don’t want to keep beating a dead horse, but this summit is amazing. You will learn, you will learn stuff. I mean, I haven’t been doing this for so long. I mean, I’ve been doing this for 10 years, but I learned a ton of stuff. And this is all I do, and I still learn a ton of stuff.
Tosh:
Well, I appreciate that, Rob. I have a very hard time accepting compliments because I just don’t see that what I do is all that special. I’m an attorney that can do elementary school math really well. And so I appreciate that. And I jumped at the opportunity to do the summit with Ken. And the Denver summit was very successful. We’re going to make some slight tweaks because it was like, oh, I think this was really good.
Let’s push this a little bit more. Basically, to try to get more interaction, because, you know, we only have 50 seats. This is not a stadium deal. It’s not 300 attorneys are going to show up at this thing. It is 50 seats because we want people to talk. We want questions, answers, ideas. Breaks. I love looking and seeing people from opposite sides of the room getting together, meeting, giving each other cards, starting to network and talk with people from other jurisdictions.
Anyway, I can’t imagine that anyone attending this would not walk away and go, holy crap. I do. And it’s just because every time I hear Ken talk, I go, holy crap. That is true. Every time I learn from Ken. And if other people can take little technical things away from my discussions and be like, oh, I hadn’t thought about that. That’s a neat subject to put into a depo, or oh, that’s a good RFP.
I should put that in my RFP set. That’s all I could ask for: is that people are learning from each other, not just Ken and I, but from each other. So, that is one thing I want to say when we talk about the summit. It’s limited seating, so that we can have those discussions. You know, you get 200 people in a room, you can’t have a discussion.
Schenk:
That’s true. And I was going to say, like, and I might have said this at the top of the show, but I seriously want to go again because of the crosstalk. Like, somebody asks a question and there’s a response from another attorney in the room or you or Ken, and it’s like, man, I didn’t even think about that. So, even though, like, I probably know the seminar and I still learn from the seminar, like, it’s the question and interaction where you’re going to get that golden nugget that makes it all worth it.
Tosh:
Exactly. And I’ll put in a plug. I mean, one of my best friends is Nicole Snapp-Holloway. I love having her at seminars where I am. You know, she speaks a lot too, but she didn’t speak in Denver. But her input was essential to those discussions because she is so technically proficient. She’s just with you and I. I mean, she’s on the technical side of it. And for her to just be, oh, well, this is how I blah, blah, blah.
And then you have Will Eady from Ohio step up and start talking. You’re just like, holy crap. You know, he’s another powerhouse guy. So you have some of the best litigators in the country sitting in that room sharing ideas. And then you’ve got younger, newer people who are sitting there going, wow, this is unbelievable. And because it’s a smaller environment, they feel comfortable asking that question that they’ve been like, oh man, this may be a stupid question, but, and they take that leap. And then realized that wasn’t a stupid question at all. That was a great question.
Schenk:
Yeah, somebody’s always thinking the same thing. And that’s why I always make sure I sit next to Nicole. Like, she also has like eight windows open, like six laptops, like, just like the Matrix.
Tosh:
Oh, yeah, she is. She’s running different AI platforms three or four at a time doing stuff. I mean, it is like the Matrix if you’re hanging out with Nicole. She is unbelievable. You know, and there’s other people that are powerhouse litigators that will be there in South Carolina. That, you know, it’s amazing. And so I am with you. I love getting up and talking just because you can tell on this podcast, I love to talk about this subject.
I am passionate about this subject. But being able to talk with my friends and meet new people and they’re getting passionate about this subject and we can start connecting. The network that I get to tap around the country when I have a question is unbelievable. And other people being able to join that network and build their network to reach out to other people and be like, hey, I’ve got a question about X.
So unbelievably powerful. You’re not alone in this fight. You may feel like it because you’re in an area of your state and you’re the only one that does nursing homes. I started in Texas. We have 1200 nursing homes. And at the time I first started doing these cases, there were four attorneys in the state of Texas that would even take a nursing home call. We had to go to the East Coast just to get any information about nursing homes.
Go to Virginia, go to New Jersey. Um, now, you know, it’s like, no, just we’re putting on presentations like this. You know, we did one in Denver, doing one in South Carolina. If South Carolina goes well, there’ll be another one sometime down the road, I imagine. But at first, we wanted to try these two, make them kind of regional. Although I was talking with somebody from Oregon today who’s going to come to South Carolina from Oregon because they are like, I’m going to be at the next one.
One of their co-workers had been in Denver with us and went back and was like, holy crap. And so now we’ve got another one coming in from Oregon that is going to come to South Carolina. Amazing. Yeah, you think about, you know, you’ve got people from Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina, all along the East Coast that will be there, but you’re going to be bringing people across the country.
And now you’ve got a network that you can start tapping and building and getting information from. And we all like to share. We’re not the least bit stingy about what we’ve learned. So, anyway, I love getting together again with my friends and I like making new friends.
Schenk:
Very well said. Well, Ernie, thank you so much for coming on the podcast, sharing your knowledge with us once again. And hopefully, everybody that’s listening to this, we will see you all in Charleston, South Carolina, on January 14th through the 15th. That’s January of 2027. January 14th through 15, 2027, Charleston, South Carolina, the summit. All the information about the summit will be in the show notes. And I’m sure that I’ll be talking about it in future episodes as well. But Ernie, thank you so much.
Tosh:
Thank you, Rob. I really appreciate it.
Schenk:
I hope that you found this episode entertaining. Again, I know it was a big commercial for the Summit CLE, which you definitely should register for. I am registered for it now.
If you did find this entertaining and educational, I highly recommend that you check out a couple of other episodes. I would start with Ernie’s first time on the show, which is episode 214 from August of 2024. And we talk about the critical pieces from nursing home cost reports, like what the cost report is and why the specific data points are important to your cases, which we would, they’re gonna talk about at the summit.
Then, episode 216 from September of ’24, where Nicole Snapp-Holloway breaks down what acuity actually means and typically how it’s factored in nursing homes, like how nursing homes figure out what acuity is. And then episode 320 from this past September, where Ernie walks through how PDPM numbers can prove a nursing home was understaffed. So that’s 214, 216, and 320. Check those out. And we’ll see you in the next episode.
Related reading: What is the Typical Day Like for a Nursing Home Resident?